Ransomware in the education sector: findings and recommendations
Sophos Bildungssektor, Cybersecurity, Ransomware
The education sector does not have a positive record when it comes to ransomware. According to the global analysis "The State of Ransomware in Education 2023" by Sophos, it is not only the sector with the most frequent attacks, but also with the highest ransom payments. Sophos presents its annual ransomware report for the education sector. "The State of Ransomware in Education 2023" shows that educational institutions have the highest rate of ransomware attacks worldwide. In the higher education sector, 79 percent and in the lower education sector, 80 percent stated that they had been victims of ransomware attacks - an increase of 64 and 56 percent respectively compared to the previous year.
More than three quarters of educational institutions (81% in the lower education sector; 73% in the higher education sector) that were affected by ransomware also had their data encrypted. In addition, 27 percent of institutions in the lower education sector and 35 percent in the higher education sector stated that their encrypted data had been stolen. Worryingly, in the education sector, the use of backups to restore encrypted data has declined over the past year, while ransomware payments have increased year on year.Finding 1: Paying ransoms makes the situation worse
The education sector recorded the highest ransom payments: 56 percent in the higher education segment and 47 percent in the lower education segment. The transfer of these amounts led to significant increases in recovery costs in both sectors. These amounted to 1.31 million US dollars (minus the ransom payments) for the higher education institutions that responded to the criminals' demands - compared to recovery from backups, which only cost 980,000 US dollars. In the case of the lower educational institutions, the average recovery costs amounted to 2.18 million US dollars if the ransom was paid and 1.37 million US dollars if no payment was made.
Paying the ransom has another disadvantage: it also extends the recovery time. In higher education, 79 percent of those who used backups were able to recover within a month, while only 63 percent of those who paid ransoms were back up and running within that time frame. At lower facilities, the difference is not quite as pronounced at 63 to 59 percent.
"Despite limited financial resources, schools are extremely attractive targets with immediate, far-reaching effects on their environments. The pressure to maintain operations and respond to calls from concerned parents leads to a desire to solve the problem quickly, regardless of cost. Unfortunately, the available data does not support the thesis that ransom payments resolve these attacks more quickly. Nevertheless, this is probably a factor that criminals take into account when choosing their victims," explains Chester Wisniewski, Field CTO at Sophos.
Insight 2: Vulnerable credentials invite cybercriminals
The education sector shows that the causes of ransomware attacks are similar to other industries, but this sector has a remarkably higher number of ransomware attacks involving compromised credentials in both higher education (37 percent) and lower education (36 percent). In comparison, the average across all sectors is 29 percent.
Further results of the Ransomware in Education Analysis 2023:More than 77 percent of ransomware attacks on higher education institutions were caused by vulnerabilities and compromised credentials (65 percent at lower institutions). The encryption rate for higher education institutions remained almost constant at 73 percent compared to 74 percent in the previous year. However, it increased from 72% to 81% at lower educational institutions. Higher education establishments reported a lower use of backups (63%) compared to the cross-industry average (70%). This is the third lowest rate across all sectors. In contrast, lower education institutions are actually slightly more likely to use backups than the global average at 73 percent.
"Educational institutions should take even more measures to better protect themselves against ransomware and other cyber attacks. For example, the misuse of stolen credentials is common for ransomware criminals in all industries, but the lack of use of multi-factor authentication (MFA) technologies in the education sector, for example, increases the risk here. It is therefore time for educational institutions of all sizes to implement MFA for teachers, pupils and students. It sets a good example and is a simple way to stop many of these attacks at the school door," says Chester Wisniewski.
Sophos also makes the following recommendations to strengthen defenses against ransomware and other cyberattacks:
-
Use security solutions that protect against the most common attack vectors. This includes endpoint protection with robust anti-exploit capabilities to prevent the exploitation of vulnerabilities and Zero Trust Network Access (ZTNA) to prevent the misuse of compromised credentials.
-
Implement adaptive technologies that automatically respond to attacks, disrupt intruders and give defenders time to respond appropriately.
-
Establish continuous threat monitoring, investigation and response around the clock. This can be done in-house or implemented by a specialist Managed Detection and Response (MDR) provider.
-
Improve attack preparation, including regular data backups, conducting exercises to restore from backups and maintaining an up-to-date emergency response plan.
-
Maintaining sound security hygiene, which includes timely updating of software patches and regular review of security tool configurations.