Nozomi Networks - CRITIS: Survey finds 'perfect storm'
Nozomi
Critical infrastructures face the same security threats as other sectors, except that the consequences for millions of people can be far more serious. That's why it's important for critical infrastructure executives to develop a comprehensive approach to security that encompasses both the physical and digital domains, known as cyber-physical systems.
A unique, global Newsweek VANTAGE survey of 415 executives responsible for critical infrastructure security shows they are aware of the need for a holistic approach to cyber-physical systems. Yet they struggle to overcome cultural resistance to transformational change, especially when it comes to IT and OT systems.
The need to overcome these long-standing obstacles is made even more urgent by the growing cyber threats and the consequences of cyber-physical security failures. Let's take a closer look at the state of critical infrastructure security in 2020.
Executives believe employees are the biggest threat to critical infrastructure security
Those who are sceptical about the need for secure cyber-physical systems should reflect on the results of the confidential survey. Nearly all critical infrastructure executives say their organisation has experienced at least one security incident in the past 12 months, and half of those have experienced two or more. Nearly a quarter say the time between compromise and discovery was more than 24 hours.
Equally worrying, employees are seen as the biggest human source of vulnerability - bigger even than cybercriminal groups. Former employees also pose a security risk. The statistics contradict the common perception that terrorists and state actors are to blame (they can wreak havoc, but it's not common).
How do these attacks occur? More than half of them are cyber attacks on IT systems, but physical attacks on IT and OT systems are also very common, and therefore it is important to look at security from both a cyber and physical perspective. Many say that a lack of integration is the main cause of vulnerability.
These figures illustrate a conundrum: the more integrated IT-OT-physical systems are, the greater the level of security, but because they are so integrated, these systems are more vulnerable to attack. Clearly, managers must balance the need for efficiency with the imperative for security.
The consequences of integration for improved performance, THEN holistic security.
Too many organisations are under the impression that their approach to cyber-physical security is adequate until they discover that it is not. Complaining can have disastrous consequences: More than a third of executives say an actual cyber breach has caused them to develop a holistic approach to their organisation's cyber-physical security.
In response to cyber-physical threats, two-thirds of executives have integrated some of their IT, OT and physical systems, and the process continues. A fifth have integrated all their systems. But the thing is, executives see the main benefits of integration as better responsiveness and decision-making. Few say integration was motivated by the need for stronger security. But experts say a holistic approach to cyber-physical security should precede steps to improve operational performance.
The biggest obstacles to better cyber-physical security
In some ways, the least surprising finding of the survey is what executives see as the main barrier to integration. People in IT and OT do not work well together, despite long-standing discussions. The survey shows that the main internal barriers to a holistic approach, both organisational and technical, are major differences between IT and OT in areas such as risk tolerances and operating environments.
Almost a third say the main barrier is cultural - i.e. resistance to change. If there was less resistance, IT and OT staff would have already settled their differences. Organisations need to change the culture so that people in IT, OT and physical security work together to mitigate threats.
The biggest external barrier to a holistic approach is that industry standards for security systems are not widespread enough, although they are available.
Since the source of friction is largely a problem involving people and their attitudes to work and their colleagues, it is logical that executives say the way to solve this problem is to have a more harmonious approach to cyber-physical security systems among people working in critical infrastructure. Nearly half of the executives surveyed say the best way to overcome barriers is to have a detailed action plan for integration supported by IT/OT/physical security teams. To change the culture, they believe security teams need to include IT/OT/physical staff.
Critical infrastructure cyber security and physical security go together
Critical infrastructure organisations focus on the physical security of their employees, customers and the public. When this is compromised, they assemble their resources to combat the threat. These organisations need to take the same approach to cyber security, especially as a cyber-physical breach could affect public health and safety.
This piece of common sense is unfortunately not common in critical infrastructure. To change the culture, four points should be considered:
- Cyber-physical standards need to be applied and, where possible, raised.
- Do things in the right order. Design policies and procedures around cyber-physical security and then invest in technology.
- Don't punish people for admitting they made a mistake. A security mistake is an opportunity to learn how to do things better.
- Cyber-physical security is not like a diet. It is a long-term lifestyle change.
If you are interested in an enterprise-wide monitoring solution that can monitor your IT, OT, as well as (I)IoT and detect anomalies such as attacks at an early stage, please feel free to contact us via phone, email or our contact form. We would also be happy to carry out a test installation at your premises to convince you of the quality of the solution.